PROMOTION 30% OFF ON THE ANNUAL PLAN

The health of Black women and the influence of the psychosocial effects of racism.

Our goal in this section is to contribute to the learning of qualitative research and its practical application, serving as a guide for those who are in the process of training, gaining knowledge, and improving their skills in this area. This time, we share a scientific article that addresses the issue of racism and its impact on the health and illness of Black women in Salvador.

To that end, the shared articles are accompanied by a brief reflective reading guide, as well as prepared answers to guide the analysis of the texts and broaden the understanding of the theoretical and methodological aspects of qualitative research.

racismo

Dos Santos, VA, Bonfim, CB, Tavares, JSC, Bernardo, KJC, & Martins, DMB (2023). The health of black women: the role of psychology in primary care. Health Society of São Paulo, 32(2): 1-11. https://www.scielosp.org/pdf/sausoc/2023.v32n2/e220410pt/pt

Summary

This study aims to analyze the perceptions of psychologists working in primary care regarding the influence of the psychosocial effects of racism and sexism on their practices and on the healthcare process for Black women. Semi-structured interviews were conducted, using Critical Social Psychology as a theoretical and methodological framework. The results show that the professionals did not identify racism as a factor influencing the health conditions of Black women seeking the service, although they highlighted gender and social class indicators. However, some of the interviewees implemented care practices based on anti-racism and anti-sexism.

Guide and Reflections on the Article

1. What is the relevance of the topic presented?

The research topic is highly relevant when addressing the health of Black women in Brazil, since structural aspects such as racism and sexism contribute to the construction of certain stereotypes that generate situations of vulnerability in this population. In this sense, intersectionality is configured as a tool for analyzing social relations in which indicators of race, class, and gender interact, producing situations of oppression and discrimination. Thus, both racism and sexism are based on beliefs and ideologies of superiority and inferiority of certain groups, associated with physical and biological characteristics that, articulated with categories of sex and gender, establish social patterns of normality. In this scenario, Black women suffer the consequences of this social dynamic, related to precariousness in various areas, prejudice in health services, and the deprivation of rights, aspects that affect their physical and mental health.

Therefore, the authors consider it fundamental to highlight the importance of the Unified Health System (SUS) in reflecting on healthcare for Black women, both due to the significant presence of this population in the services and its importance in the structure and development of Brazilian society. In particular, the primary care level is considered strategic for understanding the characteristics of the territory and the health and disease situations of the population, since one of the objectives of this level is to guarantee care to the community in which the service is located, recognizing cultural and racial aspects and their impact on community health.

2. What is the objective of the study?

The aim of this study is to analyze the perceptions of psychologists working in primary care in the municipality of Salvador regarding the influence of the psychosocial effects of racism and sexism on their practices and on the healthcare process for Black women.

3. What is the methodological design of the study?

This study is qualitative, descriptive, and exploratory in nature, as it seeks to explore a specific reality and understand the phenomenon more broadly. Its theoretical and methodological framework is Critical Social Psychology.

Eight psychologists working in Primary Health Care Units (PHCUs) and Family Health Units (FHUs) in Salvador, Bahia, participated in the study. Inclusion criteria were: being registered in the National Registry of Health Establishments (CNES), working with female patients, and participating voluntarily in the study.

For data collection, semi-structured interviews were used. However, the study does not specify which themes were addressed in the interview guide. For data analysis, the authors used the hermeneutic-dialectical method, since it is characterized as a qualitative method that aims to analyze critical social practices.

Furthermore, the article presents, in its methodological section, a series of steps in the research process that may be useful for readers who are developing research projects. In the first phase, a bibliographic review was conducted to support the definition of the research objectives, based on the study of topics considered appropriate and relevant, as well as to incorporate them into the development of the interview instrument. In the second phase, after approval from the Ethics Committee, contact was established with the study participants.

4. What are the main results of the study?

4.1. Where did the color that was here go?: an analysis of perceptions of the psychosocial effects of racism and sexism on the health of Black women.

Perceptions about pseudoneutrality

This segment of the analysis shows that the participants recognize gender issues and sexism as factors that influence the health of Black women; however, despite recognizing structural racism, they do not consider it to have an impact on the health-disease process, presenting contradictory discourses. Except in the case of certain pathologies that are predominant in certain races, such as, for example, sickle cell anemia in the Black population.

On the other hand, due to the significant presence of the Black population in these health services, the study participants do not reflect on racism in health practices.

At the same time, a certain neutrality is observed in the care provided, as highlighted by the expression "care has no color," meaning that certain psychosocial markers that impact the living conditions of Black women are not discussed.

Intersectional Perceptions

In this subcategory, it is evident that three of the participants consider the influence of racism on the care provided to women, since the experience of being a Black woman impacts the difficulty of accessing healthcare, presenting situations in which other professionals simply do not attend to these patients and in which this lack of care turns into mistreatment of this group; another of the interviewees referred to the suffering caused by structural racism.

4.2. Practices and actions for the health care of Black women in primary care, contains the following subcategories

Practices of equality without equity

Based on what was mentioned in the previous categories regarding the non-identification of racism in the health issues of Black women, this subcategory discusses the universalization of the notion of subject. Although technical norms of action are adopted, such as group care and welcoming, there is no reflection on the effects of the particular experiences of this group associated with anxiety, anguish, grief, and experiences of violence. Therefore, this is a practice decontextualized from the reality of this group, since, according to the interviewee: "My work is the same for all groups."

Anti-racist and anti-sexist practices

Among the accounts from two of the participants, the inclusion of anti-racist and anti-sexist practices in the care of some patients stands out. In this sense, the professionals are able to identify that certain health demands are associated with indicators of race, class, and gender. Therefore, care strategies or interventions aligned with these aspects are implemented.

5. What limitations of the study were identified by the researchers?

The study points out as a limitation the fact that the research was conducted online due to the Covid-19 pandemic, which affected the participants' availability for interviews and access to technological resources.

Getting to know the authors

Victoria Andrade dos Santos

Graduated in Psychology from the State University of Bahia (UNEB). Master's student in Psychology at the Institute of Psychology of the Federal University of Bahia (UFBA). Participates in the research group "Psychoanalysis: clinic, politics and culture". Member of the Dandaras Network: a health network for Black women. Has experience in the Psychosocial Care Network, with an emphasis on care for people who use alcohol and other drugs. Has an interest in the following themes: race, racism, gender, public health policies, mental health and grief. (Information from...) https://orcid.org/0009-0009-9782-9387).

Camila Barreto Bonfim

Postdoctoral researcher at the Center for Data and Knowledge Integration for Health (CIDACS). Holds a degree in Psychology, a Master's degree and a PhD in Epidemiology and Public Health from the Federal University of Bahia. Professor of Psychology at the State University of Bahia (UNEB). (Information from...) https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8361-6721).

Jeane Saskya Campos Tavares

Psychologist, Master in Community Health and PhD in Public Health (Institute of Collective Health, UFBA). Adjunct Professor at the Federal University of Recôncavo da Bahia (UFRB), based at the Center for Health Sciences (CCS/UFRB). Coordinator of the Interdisciplinary Research and Extension Group in Collective Health (GIPESC/UFRB). Associate researcher of the Research and Technical Cooperation Group FA-SA: Community, Family and Health (FASA-ISC/UFBA). Coordinator of the psychological care service for people living with chronic diseases (APC/UFRB). (Information from https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5745-1417).

Kátia Jane Chaves Bernardo

Professor in the Department of Education at the State University of Bahia. Psychologist from the Federal University of Bahia. Master's degree from the Federal University of Rio de Janeiro. PhD in History from the Federal University of Bahia. (Information from...) https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9378-709X).

Daniela Maria Barreto Martins

Adjunct Professor in the Department of Education at the State University of Bahia. PhD in Sociology from the Federal University of Pernambuco. Master's degree in Education and Contemporaneity from the State University of Bahia. Psychologist from the Federal University of Bahia. (Information from...) https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0736-8444).

Share this post:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts